Home Advocate Katy ISD unblocks LGBTQ+ websites after year of student advocacy, ACLU letter

Katy ISD unblocks LGBTQ+ websites after year of student advocacy, ACLU letter

0

After the ACLU alleged First Amendment violations, Katy ISD changed its internet policies to allow students access to websites that serve LGBTQ+ youth.

In a written response to a formal complaint from a student and a letter of support from the ACLU of Texas as well as Lambda Legal, administrators said third-party Internet filtering software used by KISD blocks websites aimed at LGBTQ+ communities that contained no pornographic material. students. After a district investigation into the complaint, an administrator said internet filters would be changed to allow access to websites for all high school students.

District officials have previously responded to inquiries about its practice of blocking the websites of organizations such as the nonprofit suicide prevention organization The Trevor Project by citing its obligation to comply with federal privacy law. Children’s Internet Protection, which requires schools to censor obscene images for minors.

Cameron Samuels, now a graduate of Seven Lakes High School who filed the formal complaint, said the policy change is a step in the right direction for the district.

“I see this as a victory,” Samuels, who is now studying politics at Brandeis University in Massachusetts, said Thursday by phone. “I am so proud to see that the hard work we have put in over these months has paid off.”

Katy ISD did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the outcome of the formal complaint or the ACLU’s allegations. However, Maria Corrales DiPetta, general manager of media relations for KISD, confirmed last week that high school students can now access the Trevor Project website.

“With respect to the website in question, its content was recently reassessed as part of standard District practice, as well as in response to a request for review,” she said. “The site was deemed acceptable and made accessible via district Wi-Fi, with the exception of the chat functionality. The site’s chat room functionality is available to minors and adults and has therefore been restricted by district Wi-Fi as per guidelines (of the Children’s Internet Protection Act).

On HoustonChronicle.com: Most push to ban books in Texas schools came from politician and GOP pressure, not parents

Brian Klosterboer, attorney for the ACLU of Texas, said most districts in the United States and Texas have taken steps to remove these filters created by third-party vendors years ago.

“It is deeply regrettable that it has taken a year of incredible activism and advocacy by Cameron and other students to bring these issues to light,” he said. “Katy ISD seems unique in how long it took to remove discriminatory web filters.”

In November, an analysis by the Houston Chronicle revealed that KISD was blocking several websites of organizations serving LGBTQ+ children, such as the Trevor Project. Other websites included the Montrose Center, a Houston nonprofit with youth services and support groups, the Human Rights Campaign and Advocate, an information source focused on the LGBTQ+ community.

Of the six other Houston-area districts that responded to a Chronicle survey, including Barbers Hill, Fort Bend, Aldine and Friendswood ISDs, none blocked the Trevor Project website to high school students.

At the time, a KISD spokesperson said its third-party Internet filtering software was based on predetermined categories that comply with the Children’s Internet Protection Act.

In April, the ACLU of Texas and Lambda Legal sent the district a letter in support of the formal complaint filed by Samuels. Their correspondence alleged that the district violated students’ First Amendment rights, citing Supreme Court precedent.

“Katy ISD’s filtering software appears to be misconfigured to block websites providing critical information and resources to lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (“LGBTQ+”) students in a discriminatory manner,” it read. in the letter.

On HoustonChronicle.com: ‘Harmful to minors’: Texas school district police officer removes book from library after complaint

In a 2012 ACLU report, the organization said it found that many districts across the country used to have web filters that specifically blocked websites with LGBTQ+ content, often at the without the knowledge of the administrators.

“Today, nearly every school district nationwide, including here in Texas, removed these discriminatory web filters that automatically block LGBTQ+ students from accessing essential information and resources,” the letter read. ACLU. “Federal law requires Katy ISD to follow suit and update its web filtering software to meet its constitutional obligations, provide the best possible learning environment for its students, and not discriminate or deny equal access essential resources for LGBTQ+ students.”

The web filtering company used by KISD, ContentKeeper, has a category called “Alternative Sexual Lifestyles (GLBT) Global,” according to district documents. In 2021, the name of the filter was changed to “Human Sexuality”, according to the district.

“Despite the name change, the Human Sexuality category continued to block LGBTQ+ websites,” Leslie Hack, deputy district superintendent, said in a written response to Samuel’s complaint.

On HoustonChronicle.com: Katy ISD assesses changes to library rules, including notifying parents when their child borrows books

Hack said in the response that none of the blocked websites in this category display pornography, adding that another filter called “Adult Content” blocks student access to pornographic images.

In January, the district continued to block websites for the Trevor Project, The Lawyer and Outsmart Magazine to students, but allowed access to some previously blocked sites, including the Montrose Center, the Human Rights Campaign man and PFLAG.

KISD also asked students to submit individual support tickets to request the unblocking of specific sites, according to the letter from the ACLU.

“Requiring students to submit individual support tickets…is not a solution to this problem either, but unacceptably forces LGBTQ+ students to ‘walk out’ and face an intimidating and discriminatory burden for access critical information,” the letter said.

The ACLU and Lambda Legal have also challenged whether students can access websites that advocate restricting LGBTQ+ rights, including Breitbart, Texas Values, and ADFLegal.

“The inconsistency of KISD’s web filtering software is shocking and particularly harmful to LGBTQ+ students,” the letter reads. “If Katy ISD students can freely access websites and information that are harmful to LGBTQ+ students, there is no reason to ban students from an essential resource like the Trevor Project that has the power to literally save the lives of LGBTQ+ students.”

After a district investigation, Hack said in August she granted Samuels’ request and said the internet filtering system would be changed to remove the “Human Sexuality” category altogether, making previously blocked websites accessible to high school students. .

According to the ACLU, the district has also created a process for elementary and middle school students to request that specific sites be unblocked at those levels.

“It’s not the full outcome we wanted, but to see that high school students can now access vital resources to assert their identity is wonderful,” Samuels said.

[email protected]